Your baby is ten days old. They have fed, burped and fed again, and they still want to suck. Your nipples are sore, it is the fourth wake-up of the night, and there is a pacifier from the baby shower sitting in a drawer. Will giving it to them now undo the breastfeeding you have worked so hard to get going?
We read what the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), the Canadian Paediatric Society, the UK's NHS and the World Health Organization each say, plus the Cochrane review that pooled the actual trials. If you are breastfeeding, hold off on the pacifier until feeding is going well, which the AAP says usually takes about 3 to 4 weeks, then offer it at naps and bedtime. That wait is cheap insurance, not a sign that pacifiers harm breastfeeding: the randomized trials pooled in a 2016 Cochrane review (Jaafar et al., 2016) are more reassuring than the warnings you may have heard.
When can you give a breastfed newborn a pacifier?
Once breastfeeding is going well, usually around 3 to 4 weeks. The AAP puts it plainly: "If you are breastfeeding, wait until breastfeeding is going well before offering a pacifier. This usually takes about 3 to 4 weeks." Its safe-sleep guide repeats the point: "If your baby is breastfed, wait until breastfeeding is established before offering a pacifier."
The Canadian Paediatric Society agrees and adds what to do if you feel you cannot wait: "It's best not to start using a pacifier until breastfeeding is going well. Talk to your doctor or lactation specialist if you feel your baby needs to use one at this early stage." Its one exception: "premature or sick babies in the hospital."
"Going well" means a comfortable latch, regular wet and dirty diapers, and steady weight gain. Our guide on how to tell if your baby is feeding well walks through each one. If you are formula feeding, the AAP says "you can start the pacifier whenever you like."
Does a pacifier cause nipple confusion or lower milk supply?
For healthy, full-term babies, the best evidence says it did not shorten breastfeeding. The worry is real and has a clear logic. As the reviewers behind a 2016 Cochrane review describe it, "offering the pacifier instead of the breast to calm the infant may lead to less frequent episodes of breastfeeding and as a consequence may reduce breast-milk production and shorten duration of breastfeeding."
But in randomized trials, that chain did not show up. The review (Jaafar et al., 2016) concluded that "pacifier use in healthy term breastfeeding infants, started from birth or after lactation is established, did not significantly affect the prevalence or duration of exclusive and partial breastfeeding up to four months of age." The reviewers rated this as moderate-quality evidence and were careful about its limits: it applies to "motivated mothers," and "there is insufficient information on the potential harms of pacifiers on infants and mothers."
The WHO's own guidance moved in the same direction. Cochrane notes that the earlier Ten Steps to Successful Breastfeeding recommended "total avoidance of artificial teats or pacifiers for breastfeeding infants." In 2018 WHO revised the Ten Steps, and Step 9 now reads: "Counsel mothers on the use and risks of feeding bottles, teats and pacifiers."
Our reading: the pacifier itself is rarely the problem. The problem is a pacifier used in place of a feed. That is why the AAP's next line matters as much as the timing: "Do not use a pacifier to replace or delay meals. Only offer it when you are sure your baby is not hungry." Early hunger cues (rooting, hands to mouth, lip smacking) are easy to mistake for a need to suck, so it is worth learning the signs your baby is hungry before the pacifier comes out. If your baby is struggling to switch between breast and bottle, that is a separate issue, covered in our guide to nipple confusion and bottle preference.
Are pacifiers good for newborns? The trade-offs
- For: a lower SIDS risk when offered at sleep (AAP; the Canadian Paediatric Society says "several studies suggest" this), and relief during "brief medical procedures."
- Against: used in place of a feed, it can mean fewer feeds. The Canadian Paediatric Society says incorrect use "can lead to problems with breastfeeding, teeth (cavities and overbite), and possibly ear infections." The AAP adds that a baby who depends on one to fall asleep "may wake up when the pacifier falls out."
For most breastfed babies, that favours waiting a few weeks, then offering it at sleep.
What each authority says, side by side
| Source | Breastfed baby: when to start | Sleep and SIDS | Main cautions |
|---|---|---|---|
| AAP (U.S.) | When breastfeeding is going well, usually about 3 to 4 weeks | Offer at nap time and bedtime; no need to put it back if it falls out | Never replace or delay a feed; never tie to crib, neck or hand |
| Canadian Paediatric Society | When breastfeeding is going well; ask a doctor or lactation specialist before then | Several studies suggest it lowers SIDS risk in the first year | Check for hunger, tiredness or boredom first; replace every 2 months |
| NHS (UK) | No week given on its SIDS page | "Think about using a dummy to settle your baby to sleep" | Lists dummies among SIDS risk-reduction steps |
| WHO | No week given | Not addressed in the Ten Steps | Step 9: counsel parents on the use and risks of bottles, teats and pacifiers |
| Cochrane review (evidence) | Trials started from birth or after lactation was established | Not assessed in this review | No significant effect on breastfeeding to 4 months; harms data insufficient |
Pacifiers and safe sleep
This is the strongest reason to use one. The AAP's safe-sleep guide says to "try giving your baby a pacifier at nap time and bedtime. Pacifiers help reduce the risk of SIDS, even if the pacifier falls out after your baby is asleep." The NHS lists it among its SIDS steps: "think about using a dummy to settle your baby to sleep – some research suggests this can help lower the risk of SIDS."
The AAP adds: "Don't hang a pacifier around your baby's neck or attach it to their clothing when they're sleeping." A pacifier adds to the basics (back to sleep, a firm flat surface, nothing else in the sleep space); it never replaces them.
Choosing and cleaning a pacifier
The AAP's shopping guidance, with the Canadian Paediatric Society's additions:
- One piece. "Look for a 1-piece model that has a soft nipple (some models can break into 2 pieces)."
- A shield too big to swallow. "The shield should be at least 1½ inches across so a baby cannot put the entire pacifier into their mouth," made of firm plastic with airholes.
- Clean before first use. Boil it (5 minutes, says the Canadian Paediatric Society) or run it through the dishwasher, then squeeze trapped hot water out with clean hands.
- Not a bottle nipple. "Do not use the nipple from a baby bottle as a pacifier. If the baby sucks hard, the nipple may pop out of the ring and choke them."
- Inspect and replace. Check for cracks or tears; the Canadian Paediatric Society says replace it every 2 months.
- Never sweeten it. The Canadian Paediatric Society says never dip it in sugar or honey, and warns against "cleaning" it by sucking on it yourself, because that "can spread germs from you to your baby."
If you are giving bottles too
If you also give the occasional bottle, the same rule applies: protect the early weeks first. A slow, paced feed matters more than any particular bottle. Our step-by-step guide to paced bottle feeding shows how to let your baby set the pace, and how to combo feed without losing your milk supply covers the supply side.
For a breastfed baby's first bottle, the BuubiBottle Mini is our 5 oz starter bottle, sized for a newborn's first feeds and for moving between breast and bottle. Its RealFeel nipple has a breast-like slope and slow flow. No bottle can promise that every baby will switch easily, so keep the first few bottles short.

BuubiBottle Mini (5 oz)
Starter bottle for breastfed newborns, with a breast-like, slow-flow RealFeel nipple.
Shop the MiniWhen to move on from the pacifier
There is no rush in the first year. The AAP's concern is later: "If your child sucks strongly on a pacifier or his thumb or fingers beyond 2 to 4 years of age, this behavior may affect the shape of their mouth or how their teeth are lining up." It adds that if a child stops before the permanent front teeth come in, "there's a good chance their bite will correct itself."
Once teething begins, a teether gives your baby something safe to gnaw that is not a sleep aid. Our guide to teething remedies that actually help covers what to try and what to skip.
Our Thiingy sensory teether is food-grade and can be chilled to soothe sore gums.

Thiingy sensory teether
Food-grade teether with rings to grip and chew; can be chilled in the fridge.
Shop ThiingyFrequently asked questions
Can I give my 1-week-old breastfed baby a pacifier?
It depends on how feeding is going. The AAP and the Canadian Paediatric Society both say to wait until breastfeeding is going well, usually about 3 to 4 weeks. If you feel your baby needs one sooner, the Canadian Paediatric Society says to talk to your doctor or a lactation specialist first.
Will a pacifier cause nipple confusion?
Probably not in a way that shortens breastfeeding, for a healthy full-term baby. The Cochrane review of randomized trials (Jaafar et al., 2016) found pacifier use "did not significantly affect the prevalence or duration of exclusive and partial breastfeeding up to four months of age." The bigger risk is using the pacifier to put off a feed, which can mean fewer feeds overall.
Should I put the pacifier back in if it falls out while my baby sleeps?
No. The AAP says you don't have to put it back in. The SIDS benefit holds "even if the pacifier falls out after your baby is asleep."
Do I have to use a pacifier to lower SIDS risk?
No. The AAP recommends offering one at naps and bedtime, but "it's OK if your baby doesn't want a pacifier." Back to sleep on a firm, flat surface with nothing else in the sleep space is the foundation either way.
Can I use a pacifier while my baby is breastfeeding well but still cluster feeding?
It depends. Cluster feeding is your baby asking for milk and helping build your supply, so feed first. The AAP's rule is to offer the pacifier only "when you are sure your baby is not hungry."
Sources
- American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org: Baby Pacifiers & Thumb Sucking: What Parents Need to Know.
- American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org: How to Keep Your Sleeping Baby Safe: AAP Policy Explained.
- Canadian Paediatric Society, Caring for Kids: Pacifiers (soothers).
- NHS: Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).
- World Health Organization: Ten steps to successful breastfeeding (2018 revision).
- Cochrane: Effect of restricted pacifier use on duration of breastfeeding in full-term infants (Jaafar et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2016, Issue 8).
Medical disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes and is not a substitute for medical advice. Guidance reflects AAP, Canadian Paediatric Society, NHS and WHO publications and the Cochrane review as published when this page was last reviewed. If your baby was premature, is not gaining weight, or you are having trouble breastfeeding, talk to your pediatrician, lactation consultant or healthcare provider before introducing a pacifier. Portions of this content draw on AI assistance and are reviewed by a qualified medical reviewer before publication.
Written by the Quark Editorial Team. Medically reviewed by Dr. Yang. Last reviewed November 3, 2026.










Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.