A parent on r/toddlers asked what to buy after the squeeze-straw cup: their daughter is 22 months, and they wanted "a stainless steel cup? Or something slightly bigger?" that is at least semi leak-proof for days out. Thirty replies later the favourites were Thermos FUNtainers, Owala, Zak, CamelBak and Simple Modern. Almost nobody mentioned the line printed on several of those product pages: ages 3 and up.
Check the maker's age label before you read the reviews. Three of the four stainless options we checked are labelled for ages 3+ on their own pages. For a child under 3, a light straw cup such as the BuubiBottle Sip covers the first step off the bottle, and the Thermos 12 oz FUNtainer, which shows no age label, is the insulated bottle for cold water on outings. After 3, the bigger Owala and Simple Modern bottles make sense.

Toddler water bottles and straw cups compared
Every cell below comes from the maker's own product page, checked on November 19, 2026. We did not bench-test the competitors. "Spare straws sold" means the maker sells replacement straw parts on its own site.
| Cup or bottle | Size and body | Keeps cold | Leaks, per the maker | Dishwasher | Maker's age label | Spare straws sold |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BuubiBottle Sip (our pick for the first cup) | 8 oz, Grilamid TR-90 polyamide | No, not insulated | Leak-proof straw with one-way valve | Whole cup, high-temperature safe | None printed; made for the move off the bottle | Not on their own yet |
| Thermos 12 oz FUNtainer | 12 oz, stainless steel | Up to 12 hours | Push-button lid covers the straw | Top rack only | None on the page | Yes, 2-pack |
| Owala Kids' FreeSip | 16 oz, stainless steel | 24 hours | Leak-proof lid | Lid yes, cup by hand | Ages 3+ | Yes, by size |
| Simple Modern Summit Kids | 14 oz, stainless steel | "For hours" | Leak-proof with the nozzle closed | Top rack, lid washed open | Not under 3 | Not confirmed |
| Klean Kanteen 10 oz Kid's Cup, straw lid | 10 oz, stainless steel | Not claimed | Splash-proof, "NOT leakproof" | Yes | Ages 3+ | Straw lid 2-pack |
| Open cup, no lid | Any small cup | No | Spills, by design | Usually | AAP: aim for it by about 2 | Nothing to replace |
Our read of the table: under 3, use the Sip (or any light, valve-straw cup that goes in the dishwasher) at home and in the car seat, and the Thermos FUNtainer when you need cold water for hours. Practise an open cup at meals either way. Parents also named Zak, CamelBak and YETI; we could not read those makers' product pages from our checker, so they are not in the table.
Start with the age on the label
The parent in the thread has a 22-month-old. Here is what the bottles parents recommended say about age on their own pages:
- Owala lists the Kids' FreeSip as "Ages 3+".
- Simple Modern's Summit Kids page says "Not for children under 3 years old".
- Klean Kanteen's 10 oz Kid's Cup is "Recommended for ages 3+".
- The Thermos 12 oz FUNtainer page gives no age range.
None of the pages says why. It may be the mouthpiece, the weight or simply how the product was tested, and we would be guessing. If your child is under the label age, follow the label or ask the maker before you buy. A one-year-old will not mind that their cup is less exciting than a sibling's bottle.
The when-to-switch question, from bottle to sippy, straw and open cup, has its own guide: sippy cup age: when to introduce sippy, straw and open cups. The short version from the AAP is to offer a cup around 6 months when solids start, finish moving off the bottle between 12 and 18 months, and aim for an open cup by about 2 years.
Leaks: read what "leak-proof" covers
"Leak-proof" on a product page almost always means leak-proof when closed. Simple Modern says its straw lid is "leak-proof when the nozzle is in the closed position". Owala says the Kids' FreeSip will never leak "when closed". Klean Kanteen is the most direct: its straw lid is splash-proof but "NOT leakproof", which makes it a cup for the table, not the bag.
Thermos does not use the word on the 12 oz FUNtainer page. Its lid is a push button that "covers the silicone straw when not in use", and that cover is what parents in the thread liked: "Both have lids that cover the mouthpiece when on the go," one wrote of Thermos and Owala. Another parent liked that the Thermos lid covers the straw "so it doesn't get nasty out and about".
The BuubiBottle Sip uses a different approach: a two-piece straw with a one-way valve, so the cup does not pour out when tipped. That is why it works in a car seat or on the floor of a stroller. The trade-off is that a valve means your toddler has to suck to drink, which matters for the AAP point below.
Cleaning: count the parts you have to see into
"Just make sure you can see all the parts so that there isn't hidden mildew," one parent advised, adding that "some aren't dishwasher safe". Both points separate these bottles more than the colours do.
- Dishwasher. Thermos and Simple Modern say top rack, and Simple Modern wants the lid washed in the open position. Owala's lid is dishwasher safe but the cup is hand wash. The Klean Kanteen cup and the whole BuubiBottle Sip go in the dishwasher, and the Sip is also listed as high-temperature safe.
- Straw parts. Thermos straws come as a soft silicone top and a hard stem, and Thermos sells both as a 2-pack. The top Thermos reply in the thread liked exactly that: "they sell replacement straws/valves." The Sip's straw is two pieces too, and its wide mouth leaves room for a bottle brush.
- Replacing parts. A CamelBak parent in the same thread said they "just keep replacing the silicon parts every 2-3 months". There is no official schedule; replace a straw when it is torn, chewed through or you can no longer get it clean.
If silicone versus plastic parts matters to you, our guide to food-grade silicone explains what the labels mean.
Insulated steel or light plastic
The steel bottles win on one thing: cold water stays cold. Thermos claims up to 12 hours and Owala 24 hours. On a summer outing that is real value. Thermos, Owala and Simple Modern all say not to use their bottles for hot liquids, and Owala's FAQ adds the Kids' FreeSip is "Not for use with hot, carbonated, or perishable liquids", so milk is not what these are for.
Plastic wins on weight and on what happens when the cup is thrown. The Sip's body is Grilamid TR-90, a polyamide the maker describes as shatterproof and lightweight, with no steel wall to dent. Steel bottles have their own wear points: one parent noted their Klean Kanteen's "rubber of the air vent hole fell out already so it leaks a lot now" (they did not say which model). For how polyamide compares with other bottle plastics, see polyamide vs PPSU, and our guide to reading material claims covers what "BPA-free" does and does not tell you.
Chewers are their own category. Two parents in the thread moved away from silicone straws because their toddler bit through them; one liked Owala because "the mouthpiece is plastic and can't really be chewed". The Sip's straw is soft silicone, so a determined chewer will wear it down.
Where the BuubiBottle Sip fits, and where it doesn't

We make the Sip, so here it is plainly. It is built on the same 8 oz Grilamid TR-90 bottle as our BuubiBottle Max, with a two-piece silicone straw, a one-way valve and a grip collar with handles. Its parts interchange with BuubiBottle feeding bottles, so a baby who drank from a BuubiBottle picks up something familiar. The one-bottle system guide explains what changes between stages.
Where it falls short:
- Not insulated. In a hot car the water warms. For long summer outings, the Thermos does the job better.
- 8 oz. Smaller than the 12 to 16 oz steel bottles. For a toddler that is one cup of water per fill, so pack a refill for a long day.
- It has a valve. The AAP prefers valve-free sippy cups and an open cup by about 2. Use the Sip as a learning and travel cup, not the only cup.
- Soft straw. Chewers will wear it down, and today we do not sell Sip straws on their own.

BuubiBottle Sip
8 oz shatterproof straw cup with a leak-proof valve straw and handles; the whole cup goes in the dishwasher.
Shop BuubiBottle SipHome cup, bag bottle, bedtime
Most families end up with two or three cups doing different jobs, and the AAP guidance sorts them neatly.
- At meals: an open cup, or a straw cup while your child is still learning. The AAP says to "Offer cups mainly at mealtime," and milk belongs here too.
- Between meals and out of the house: plain water only. The AAP's tooth-care page puts it this way: "Milk, breast milk and formula can be given at mealtimes, but fill your child's cup with plain water in between." Pack it in the bag with the rest of the diaper bag checklist.
- Bedtime and soothing: no cup. The same AAP page says to "avoid using cups or bottles to soothe your child," because sipping milk or juice for long periods bathes the teeth in sugar.

One parent's summary is worth keeping in mind before buying a fourth bottle: "We got all the fancy water bottles and honestly sometimes kids just like simple things."
Common questions
Can a 2-year-old use an Owala or Simple Modern kids' bottle?
No, not by the makers' labels. Owala labels the Kids' FreeSip for ages 3+, and Simple Modern says the Summit Kids is not for children under 3. Klean Kanteen recommends its 10 oz Kid's Cup for ages 3+. If your child is younger, use a cup without that label, such as the Thermos 12 oz FUNtainer or a toddler straw cup.
Are straw cups better than sippy cups?
It depends on the valve. The AAP says a cup with a straw or an open cup are both fine, and if you use a sippy cup to choose one with no valve, because a valve makes a child suck as they would on a bottle. It also says sippy cups are for learning and that an open cup by about 2 is healthiest. Our sippy, straw and open cup guide covers how to teach each one.
How much water does a toddler need?
The AAP gives 1 to 4 cups (8 to 32 oz) a day for children 12 to 24 months, and 1 to 5 cups (8 to 40 oz) for ages 2 to 5. An 8 oz cup holds one of those cups; a 16 oz bottle holds two. If your toddler is unwell and not drinking, see what to feed a sick toddler and when to call.
Can I put milk in an insulated water bottle?
Not in the Owala. Owala's FAQ says its Kids' FreeSip is not for hot, carbonated or perishable liquids. More generally, the AAP suggests milk at meals and plain water between them, so a bottle that rides around all day should hold water.
How often should I replace the straw?
There is no official schedule. Replace a straw when it is torn, chewed through or you can no longer get it clean. Makers that sell spares, such as Thermos and Owala, make that easy; one CamelBak parent swaps the silicone parts every 2 to 3 months.
Is the BuubiBottle Sip insulated?
No. The Sip is a light, shatterproof polyamide cup with a valve straw, and it goes in the dishwasher whole. If cold water for hours is the priority, choose an insulated steel bottle that is labelled for your child's age. For packing a full day out, see our travel feeding kit.
Our picks
For the first step off the bottle, under 3 or not: the Sip. For cold water on long days out, under 3: the Thermos 12 oz FUNtainer. For a 3-year-old who wants a big-kid bottle: Owala Kids' FreeSip or Simple Modern Summit Kids. Building a list for the toddler years? Our feeding registry that grows with your baby covers the rest.
BuubiBottle Sip
Our pick for the first cup after the bottle: light, valve straw, dishwasher safe.
Shop SipSources
- American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org: From Bottle to Cup: Helping Your Child Make a Healthy Transition (last updated July 3, 2023).
- American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org: Recommended Drinks for Children Age 5 & Younger (last updated October 3, 2023).
- American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org: Why It's Important to Take Care of Baby Teeth (last updated January 20, 2026).
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention: Fingers, Spoons, Forks, and Cups (March 11, 2026).
- Thermos: 12oz FUNtainer Water Bottle and Replacement Straws 2-Pack, checked November 19, 2026.
- Owala: Kids' FreeSip, FAQ and Replacement Straws, checked November 19, 2026.
- Simple Modern: Summit Kids Water Bottle with Straw Lid, checked November 19, 2026.
- Klean Kanteen: 10oz Kid's Cup with Straw Lid and Kid's Cup Straw Lid 2-Pack, checked November 19, 2026.
- Parent discussion, r/toddlers: Toddler water bottle recommendations?
Medical disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes and is not a substitute for medical advice. Guidance reflects AAP and CDC publications as dated above. If your child has trouble swallowing, a medical condition, or is not drinking enough, ask your pediatrician. We compared manufacturers' published information and did not bench-test competitors' products. Portions of this content draw on AI assistance and are reviewed by a qualified medical reviewer before publication.
Medically reviewed by Dr. Yang. Last reviewed November 19, 2026.









Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.